Guest Stars Chinaza Uche as Henry Sophie Zucker as Abby Allegra Heart as Abiah Darlene Hunt as Maggie Gus Birney as Jane Humphreys Robert Picardo as Ithamar Conkey Matt Lauria as Ben Newton Co Starring Mark Rosa as Piano Player Ashley Carvalho as Twin Sister A Kimberly Carvalho as Twin Sister B Yoni Raanan Kallai as Acrobat #1 Angela Elaine Butch as Acrobat #2