Guest Stars Genevieve Padalecki as Ruby Rachel Miner as Meg Masters Lisa Berry as Billie Danneel Ackles as Sister Jo / Anael Co Starring William C. Vaughan as Demon Jesse Blue as TBD David H. Lyle as Man with a Broken Foot Amélie Eve as A Girl in the Garden Uncredited Jared Padalecki as Alternate Universe Hipster Sam Jensen Ackles as Alternate Universe Hipster Dean