Guest Stars Daniel Henshall as Leonard Patz Ben Taylor as Derek Yoo Jordan Alexa Davis as Sarah Grohl Megan Byrne as Joan Rifkin Patrick Fischler as Dan Rifkin Tamara Hickey as Toby Maria Elena Ramirez as Cara Myra Lucretia Taylor as Judge Rivera Co Starring Shawn Fitzgibbon as Detective Peterson Liam Kilbreth as Ben Rifkin Ted Arcidi as Kingston Odis Spencer as Principal Carrie Ann Quinn as Kathleen Michele Proude as Court Clerk Frankie Francois as Sienna Aaron Andrade as Mr. Fuller Gene Dante as Ian Collin Knight as Police Officer Gary Kirby as Older Man Mai Delapa as Katie Alfred Briere as Molloy Rebecca Gibel as Wendy Angela Hope Smith as Molloy's Counsel Shannon Ashe as Christine Ian Lyons as Burt Knox Melissa McMeekin as Roxanne