Guest Stars Kathleen Munroe as Rachael Braidwood James Tupper as Dr. Eric Ward Gary Weeks as Deputy Andrew Chartman Ned Bellamy as Samuel Catlin April Billingsley as Barbara Langston Co Starring Kevin Sizemore as Gary Humphrey Christopher Berry as Deputy Carl Enders Jwaundace Candece as Mrs. Camille Thompson Nadej K Bailey as Jenny Thompson Michael Harding as Paul Thorton Shawn Shepard as Mr. Wallace Thompson Garrett Kruithof as Confused Man Ashlee Payne as Polly Humphrey Victor Cordova as Bob Clark Avis-Marie Barnes as Sharon Tracy Goode as Sheriff's Deputy #1 Gabriel Davis as Sheriff's Deputy #2 Kristin Erickson as Server Dane Davenport as Korean War Officer