Guest Stars Derek Mears as Moloch Neil Jackson as Abraham Van Brunt Sakina Jaffrey as Sheriff Leena Reyes Patrick Gorman as Reverend Knapp Timothy Busfield as Benjamin Franklin Co Starring Jeremy Owens as Headless Horseman Craig Branham as Headless Horseman Matt Mercurio as Duty Officer Ed Dabney as War Luke Smith as Kindred Michael Rosander as Bank Salesman Jared Simon as Polygraph Examiner Benjamin Rowe as Orderly #3 Christopher Eaddy as Orderly #1 Eric Mainade as War (Weapons)