Special Guest Stars Barbara Eden as Crystal Simpson Guest Stars Dick York as Elwood P. Gilroy J. Pat O'Malley as Judge Thaddeus Fillmore Roy Barcroft as Sheriff Norman Leavitt as Miner Harry Lauter as Orville Tippet Roy Roberts as Town Mayor Byron Foulger as Farmer Dick Wessel as Jed Uncredited Jaye Durkus as Drover Rudy Doucette as Drover Archie Butler as Drover Cap Somers as Townsman Allen Jaffe as Townsman Chick Sheridan as Cowhand Len Hendry as Townsman Pete Kellett as Trial Spectator John Roy as Trial Spectator Charles Horvath as Cowboy Emile Avery as Townsman Regis Parton as Cowboy Arnold Roberts as Townsman Dee Cooper as Trial Spectator John Breen as Juror Forest Burns as Townsman Henry Wills as Cowboy Tom Kennedy as Juror Russell Custer as Trial Spectator John Barton as Townsman Phil Schumacher as Bartender Nick Borgani as Townsman Jimmy Noel as Juror George Blagoi as Juror Bill Coontz as Trial Spectator