Special Guest Stars Ryan O'Neal as Max Keenan Guest Stars Patricia Belcher as Asst. U.S. Attorney Caroline Julian Loren Dean as Russ Brennan Bess Wohl as Amy Hollister Alessandra Torresani as Teenaged Girl Elf David DeLuise as Santa Jeff Mantell Reginald VelJohnson as Dale Owens Ernie Grunwald as Santa Fred Spivak Kacie Borrowman as Little Person Elf Donovan Scott as Santa Larry David Doty as Ralph Harley David Ackert as Marty Moussa Co Starring Ty Panitz as Parker Booth Skye Casey Arens as Hayley Hollister Antonia Michael Fuller as Emma Hollister Robert Dahey as Chinese Waiter Martin Chow as Santa Chang