Guest Stars Mike Faiola as Kevin Hamilton Barret Swatek as Ally Saxton Wesam Keesh as Kyle Cohen Evan Crooks as Theo Abbott Monty Geer as Cole Higgins Kofi Siriboe as Tyler Elizabeth Whitson as Eva Mansfield Amanda Foreman as Barbara McKibben Haley Lu Richardson as Mackenzie Co Starring Todd Sherry as Store Manager David Coe as Junior Stoner Matthew Frias as Freshman Nerd