Guest Stars Tina Huang as Susie Chang Chris Vance as LTC Charles "Casey" Jones Amaury Nolasco as Lt. Det. Rafael Martinez Andrea Bordeaux as Barista Vanessa Bell Calloway as Assistant District Attorney Piper Curda as Megan Sammi Hanratty as Chloe Dyana Liu as Karine Thomas Chris Tallman as David Sutton Alexis Raich as Samantha Leah Bateman as Emma Christopher May as Mr. Cole Meryl Hathaway as Mrs. Sutton Kevin Rock as Principal Roger Appleton Tricia Leigh Fisher as Mrs. Cole