Guest Stars Artemis Pebdani as Artemis Caitlin Carmichael as Samantha Emily Evan Rae as Justine Erik Jensen as Walter Harris Maxim Knight as Benjamin Co Starring Madison Moellers as Lauren Brian Lally as Detective Haney Cory Blevins as Benjamin's Dad Anise Fuller as Aimee's Mom Jennifer Ann Massey as Ashley's Mom Zarii Arri as Aimee Vanessa Celso as Justine's Mom Kaitlyn Nakatani as Kristen Bobbie Prewitt as Ashley John Wiltshire as Mort
