Guest Stars Jay R. Ferguson as Stan Rizzo Alison Brie as Trudy Campbell Kevin Rahm as Ted Chaough Stephanie Drake as Meredith James Wolk as Bob Benson Trevor Einhorn as John Mathis Linda Cardellini as Sylvia Rosen Kit Williamson as Ed Brynn Horrocks as Abigail Whitman Brian Markinson as Dr. Arnold Rosen Brandon Killham as Dick John Sloman as Raymond Geiger Morgan Rusler as Mack Johnson Gary Basaraba as Herb Rennet Kip Pardue as Tim Jablonski Megan Ferguson as Ms. Swenson Yaani King Mondschein as Phyllis Katie Walder as Sherry Collette Wolfe as Brenda Marty Dew as Hugh Hibbert Oliver Muirhead as John Echolls Keenan Henson as Doug Toni Torres as Lucy Bryan Chesters as Bill Julie Alexander as Ernestine Co Starring Peter Arpesella as Waiter