Guest Stars Zahn McClarnon as Officer Mathias Irene Bedard as May Stillwater T.J. Alvarado as Dillon Kimberly Guerrero as Neena Wapasha Co Starring Ralph Alderman as Judge Joseph Mayhew Kenneth Ruthardt as Hugo Tenderfoot Alexander Thorne as Bailiff Amber Midthunder as Lilly Stillwater Faye Viviana as Michaela Grey Wolf Ernest Tsosie III as Announcer J.R. Garfield as Ada Vondra