Guest Stars Ray Ford as Luther Wilson Eve Gordon as Connie Colburn Rosalind Chao as Pastor Jin Dean Cain as Himself Shanti Lowry as Valentina Delgado Karina Smirnoff as Herself Co Starring Jennie Pierson as Pepper Billy Keane as Billy Kiplan Dooley as Billy Gayla Johnson as Female Crew Member Jake Dogias as Bar Patron Dominic Dierkes as Oscar Shane Nickerson as Midwestern Father Aidan Lewis as Young Boy