Guest Stars Reed Diamond as Laurence Dominic Amy Acker as Dr. Claire Saunders Miracle Laurie as Mellie / November Aisha Hinds as Loomis Gregg Henry as William Bashford Ian Anthony Dale as Jack Dunston Jordan Bridges as Nicolas Bashford Rhea Seehorn as Jocelyn Bashford Damien Leake as Minister Co Starring Brenda Bakke as Margaret Bashford Vincent Larusso as Buddy #2 Erik McDowell as Buddy #1