Guest Stars Frank McGrath as Charlie Wooster Terry Wilson as Bill Hawks Peggy Webber as Millie Collins Allen Case as Jim Collins Michael Hinn as Townsman Emile Meyer as Capt. John Pederson Brian Donlevy as Jasper Cato David McMahon as Special Patrol Officer Fred Sherman as Judge Credit Only Robert Horton as Flint McCullough Uncredited Jack Tornek as Townsman on Horse Herman Hack as Townsman Lillian O'Malley as Townswoman Fred Aldrich as Courtroom Spectator Chick Hannan as Townsman Leonard P. Geer as Townsman Charles Sullivan as Dock Worker