Guest Stars Eric Keenleyside as Steve Hitchcock Co Starring Liam James as Young Shawn Sage Brocklebank as Buzz McNab Olivia Cheng as Bad Nanny Leah Gibson as Slut Sarah Lind as Ada Leela Savasta as Nanny Nicole Oliver as Abby Daniels Patricia Isaac as Perfect Nanny Jennifer Shirley as Psycho Elizabeth Weinstein as Receptionist Darien Provost as Little Boy Vanessa Marley as Cloth Overall Nanny Ryley Holt as Twin Boy #2 Nicholas Holt as Twin Boy #1 Danika Czubak as Ditzy Nanny Jane Stanton as Slob Gerry South as Anthony Ogletree Christine Anton as Margaret Jeremy Radick as Carl Kozlowski Kennedy Montano as Little Girl Bernadeta Wrobel as Jaynie D. Harlan Cutshall as Gary Mills