Special Guest Stars Cybill Shepherd as Dr. Madeleine Spencer Guest Stars Christopher McDonald as Paul Haversham Todd Stashwick as Frankjim Ogletree Co Starring Elysia Rotaru as Lantern Lady Natasha Peck as Shawn's Girlfriend Debbie Timuss as Bianca Marco Soriano as Waiter Balinder Johal as Hadewych Jodie Graham as Henry's Partner Andrea Lai as Katie