Special Guest Stars Mark Hamill as James Montgomery Jesse / The Trickster Guest Stars Vito D'Ambrosio as Tony Bellows Mike Genovese as Lt Warren Garfield Biff Manard as Michael Murphy Richard Belzer as Joe Kline Gloria Reuben as Sabrina Joyce Hyser as Megan Lockhart Brad Sevy as Waiter Corinne Bohrer as Zoey Clark Parley Baer as Judge Marsha Clark as Denise Cowan