Guest Stars Patrick Warburton as David Puddy Joe Lala as Priest Raye Birk as Mr. Pless Katy Selverstone as Siena Mark DeCarlo as Alec Berg Pierrino Mascarino as Father Hernandez Lawrence LeJohn as Crowd Member David Powledge as Fan #2 Peggy Lane O'Rourke as Waitress Jan Eddy as Fan #3 Dave Richardson as Fan #1 Uncredited Fred Stoller as First Man in Hockey Audience Donald Gibb as Letter S in Devils Body Painter