Guest Stars Johanna Braddy as Tammy Bradstone David Starzyk as Matt Bradstone Andy Milder as Cy Tracy Middendorf as Lyla Bradstone Co Starring Nawal Bengholam as Medical Examiner Michael Monken as Jeff Sean Ryan Fox as Young Cy Kristen Ariza as Detective Bonner Chloe June O'Shannon as Cheryl Lindsay LaVanchy as Beth Jimmy Deshler as Teen Cy Monique Green as Debbie Cynthia Eades as Mrs. Westerly Harry Daniels as Bully Kid #2 Katelyn Pacitto as Young Lyla Kevin Norman as Teen Matt Caroline Schreiber as Abby Elcott Peg London as Mrs. Elcott Troy Lindsay Brown as Bully Kid #1 Paul Butler as Jason Bradstone Kinna McInroe as Gwen Jessi Cooper as Sarah Doug Morency as Mr. Elcott