Special Guest Stars Conan O'Brien as Himself Guest Stars Keith Powell as James "Toofer" Spurlock Katrina Bowden as Cerie Maulik Pancholy as Jonathan Chris Parnell as Dr. Leo Spaceman Dean Winters as Dennis Duffy Rachel Dratch as Blue Man Co Starring Kevin Brown as Walter "Dot Com" Slattery Grizz Chapman as Warren "Grizz" Griswold Aubrey Plaza as Page Johnnie Mae as Nurse Dave Finkel as 2nd AD Steven Hollander as Conan Stage Manager Rao Rampilla as Fruit Salesman