Guest Stars Jayne Atkinson as FBI Section Chief Director Erin Strauss Nicholas Brendon as Kevin Lynch Patrick Breen as Peter Harper Andrew Bowen as Mark Jackson Co Starring Genevieve Levin as Reporter Stephen Simon as Sam Elizabeth Higgins Clark as Tammy Trevor Jackson as Tyler Rogers Ayumi Iizuka as Call Center Operator David Bickford as Dr. Montgomery Houston Ally Iseman as Laurel Tyson Jacquelyn Zook as Nicole Francis Lauren Marie Klausmeyer as Kayla Jefferson Sean Solan as John Butler Stephanie Jones as Leslie Hopkins William Charlton as Detective Paul Boseman Gita Reddy as M.E. Marvi Hatcher