Guest Stars Kevin Weisman as Dr. Jeffrey Maynard Anthony Carrigan as Harris Holt Michael Cullen as Cardinal Richards Caitlin Mehner as Lisa Neil / Amy Dowd Andrew Dolan as Gerald Sullivan Bernadette Quigley as Mrs. Dowd Maury Ginsberg as Dr. Cambell Meyer David Pittu as James Wagner Co Starring Bazzel Baz as Baz Blair Busbee as Zoe Antonio Thompson as Brother Joseph Gregory Casimir as Guard Hannah Schulze Eisendrath as Teenager Judy McLane as Brenda Rachel Napoleon as Meryl Amy Russ as Young Mom J. Cameron Barnett as Hairdresser Tim Barker as William Dowd