Guest Stars Kate Micucci as Heather Adam Rose as Ken Scarlett Lam as Jeanie Shanna Collins as Shana Nikki Boyer as Pedicurist Eddie Pepitone as Homeless Nick Josh Gundling Williamson as Employee Robbie Samantha Streets as Anna Caitlin Crosby as Kelly Evan Sabara as Kid in Locker Jeff Braine as AJ Jozef Fahey as Mike Amy Halloran as Carla Uncredited James Rodriguez as Jamie Lukas Rodriguez as Jamie Kelli Barksdale as Morp Jesse Bostick as Morp Brooks McBeth voices Trevor