Andy begins his comeback on the job by teaming with Bobby and Diane to investigate a double-homicide at an auto repair store. The cops figure out the perpetrator is a veteran convict facing life without parole, but his good-citizen brother refuses to rat on his sibling. After Andy tells the convict the story of Andy Jr., he convinces the good brother to tell the truth. James, Greg and Adrienne Lesniak catch the case of two murdered junkies. They figure out that another junkie killed them, and the hard part is telling the truth about this to one of the victim's estranged husband, who still loved his wife and is devastated by her death. The new PAA is transferred out by Fancy because she's not competent, Greg finds a nice apartment he can afford, PAA John Irvin leaves the department to start his own business, Bobby and Diane decide to take some vacation time together, and Andy prays for the first time in a very long time during his son Theo's Greek Orthodox birthing ceremony.