Guest Stars Kimberly Huie as Mattie Kinkaid Matthew Del Negro as Ben Lewis Peter Hermann as Luke Dalton Janaya Stephens as Ms. Newburg Jeff Geddis as Jeremy Rupa Aggarwal as Eloni Erin Wasson as TBD Co Starring Melanie Scrofano as Emma Daniel Fathers as Richard Manning Danielle Gulic as Heather Lauren Lipson as Nina David Benjamin Tomlinson as Stage Manager Tiffany Lyndall-Knight as Carolyn Monique Moses as Over Dancing Woman Koal Harrison as Young Jeremy