Special Guest Stars Paula Abdul as Judge Paula Guest Stars Vickie Eng as Judge Rita Mayson Rhoda Griffis as Paula Dewey David Denman as Tony Nicastro Devon Gummersall as Ethan Alicia Coppola as Dr. Dumont Lina Esco as Lina Martinez Wendell Pierce as Neal David Bryce Johnson as Eric Hayes Christopher Gartin as Mr. Hess Yancy Benard Foister as Tap Dancer