Guest Stars Ito Aghayere as Reporter Kristine Johnson Sean Cullen as Gordon Frost Kathleen Wise as Female Neighbor Peter Scanavino as Alex Tom Bateman as Librarian #1 Jeremy Beck as John Patton Lou Martini, Jr. as Building Manager Scott Sowers as Marty Eleanor Reissa as Librarian #2 Mariusz Kubicki as Harold Michael Matera as Transit Cop