Guest Stars Chris Messina as Chris Sanchez Judd Hirsch as Bill Herndon Debra Monk as Deniece Parsons Derek Webster as Anthony Carter Bailey Chase as Sean Everett Co Starring Li Jun Li as Maggie Huang Kiley Liddell as Catherine Hewes Stephen McGahan as 6 Year Old Erickson Brandon Thane Wilson as 16 Year Old Erickson Jesse Dean Montana as 13 Year Old Erickson Drew Beasley as 9 Year Old Erickson Seth Barrish as Robert Owen Usman Ally as Nasim Marwat Bruce Altman as Jim Girotto Dana Brooke as Receptionist Robert Stanton as Pastor Stephen Yates Fawad Siddiqui as Shahbaz Gul Sevan Greene as Male Cashier Naeem Uz-Zaman as Prayer Leader