Guest Stars Minka Kelly as Gaby John Corbett as Seth Holt Mark Edward Smith as Principal Gomez Blake Young-Fountain as Arnie's Friend Jeff Rosick as Arnie Michael Emerson as Amazing Andy Aramis Knight as Judah June Carryl as Miss Hillary Chad Addison as Two Other Guys in Cage #1 Julie Wittner as Amy Khleo Thomas as Guy in Cage Maxim Knight as Henry Keith Campbell as Teacher Jered Solow as Two Other Guys in Cage #2
