Guest Stars Bellamy Young as Mellie Grant Joshua Malina as David Rosen George Newbern as Charlie Kate Burton as Sally Langston Brian Letscher as Tom Larsen Matt Letscher as Billy Chambers Stoney Westmoreland as Hal Rimbeau Brendan Hines as Gideon Wallace Liza Weil as Amanda Tanner Leslie Grossman as Lisa Amanda Fuller as Carly Weston Darren Pettie as Andrew Mackleson Graham Beckel as Hank Tanner Lenora May as Phyllis