Guest Stars Ana Nogueira as Penny Ares Co Starring Tierney Mumford as Elizabeth "Lizzie" Saltzman Lily Rose Mumford as Josette "Josie" Saltzman Chaka Desilva as Shaman Aisha Duran as Virginia St John Andrea Laing as EMT Keith N. Collis as Mechanic Uncredited Nina Dobrev voices Elena Gilbert