Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Sami Gayle as Nicole "Nicky" Reagan-Boyle Tony Terraciano as Jack Reagan Richard Kline as Judge Angioli Sarah Steele as Rebecca Megan Boone as Candice Richard Masur as Assemblyman Shapiro Luke Kirby as Detective Wolf Landsman Susan Misner as Karen Waters Bruce Altman as Robert Levitt Darren Goldstein as Asher Lefko Moti Margolin as Huge Hasid Fyvush Finkel as Moishe Yuval Boim as Levi Heather Marie Wolf as Bridget Gregg Bello as Benny Roth David Margulies as Solomon Stephen Kunken as Jacob Melissa Errico as Rivka Morganthal Co Starring Chris Fischer as Officer Calica Cliff Moylan as Officer Calica Alice Barden as Attorney Allen Lewis Rickman as Hasidic Man Belinda Johnson as Levitt's Wife Charlie Garber as Hasidic Prayer Leader