Guest Stars Brian Benben as Dr. Sheldon Wallace James Morrison as William White Josh Hopkins as Dr. Noah Barnes Idina Menzel as Lisa King Max Burkholder as Ben King Charlie McDermott as Bobby Douglas Melinda Page Hamilton as Donna Keating Elise Neal as Janine Mathew St. Patrick as Malcolm Co Starring Bill Miller as Dr. Mason Adam Lazarre-White as Phillip Meeghan Holaway as Barbara Tim Quill as Ted Micah May as Cop Charli Lindqvist as ER Nurse