Guest Stars Henry Winkler as Eddie R. Lawson Meredith Hagner as Libby Ezra Miller as Tucker Bryant Zoe McLellan as Kim Zachary Booth as Oliver Ambrose Co Starring Alex Dreier as Young Evan Noah Zaleman as Young Hank David Hess as Mr. Ambrose Jamil Mena as Fireman Gene Edward Cordiano as Young Eddie Curt Bouril as Kim's Husband