Guest Stars Laura Benanti as Shelby Shackelford Frances Conroy as Blythe Ballard Alexandra Socha as Molly O'Shea Brad Beyer as Don O'Shea Matt Malloy as Dr. Oren Sal Rendino as Stu Laura Bell Bundy as Gina Black Drew McVety as Bobby Moxley Martin LaPlatney as Husband Nick Sullivan as Choir Member #2 Peggy J. Scott as Wife Sidney Williams as Clerk Pippa Pearthree as Choir Member #1