Guest Stars Michael Reilly Burke as Eric Whitley Kate Mara as Jill Shelby D.W. Moffett as Todd Whitley Mo McRae as Burke Kelvin Lisa Waltz as Melanie Whitley Sherman Howard as Tim Dorn Elizabeth Franz as Evelyn Shelby Lillian Hurst as Bonita Rafael Tim Choate as Charlie Winters Co Starring Becki Newton as Young Melanie Finn Wittrock as Young Eric Diana Burbano as Bonita at 35 Kip Martin as Young Todd Robert Walters as Young Charlie Croix Lazzara as Brayson