Guest Stars Brad Leland as Buddy Garrity Brooke Langton as Jackie Miller Aasha Davis as Waverly Grady Jae Head as Bo Miller Alexandra Holden as Suzy Quinnlen Co Starring Blue Deckert as Mac McGill Timothy F. Crowley as Coach Crowley Louanne Stephens as Lorraine Saracen Aaron Spivey-Sorrells as Coach Spivey Libby Villari as Mayor Lucy Rodell Joey Truty as Buddy Garrity Jr. Merrilee McCommas as Pam Garrity James Powers as Bradley Cole Aundrus Poole as Reggie Seale Kate Krause as Tabitha "Tabby" Garrity Ryan Ciardo as Chuck Pierce William Bradley Wright as Terrence Boyd Mark Gil as Det. Kirk Dunver Terrenee Knight as Rosario Will Parsons as Non-Panther Student