Guest Stars Brad Leland as Buddy Garrity D.W. Moffett as Joe McCoy Jeremy Sumpter as Joe Doyle "J.D." McCoy Kim Dickens as Shelby Garrett Janine Turner as Katie McCoy Zach Roerig as Cash Waller Co Starring Derek Phillips as Billy Riggins Timothy F. Crowley as Coach Crowley Louanne Stephens as Lorraine Saracen David Cowgill as Slammin' Sammy Meade Stacey Oristano as Mindy Collette Libby Villari as Mayor Lucy Rodell Drew Waters as Wade Aikmen Anthony Solomon as Charles White Sinqua Walls as Jamarcus Hall Brent Craft as Jenkins Nora Jessamyn as April Keegan / April Keenan Brooke Peoples as Brooke ("Justin Girl") George Hertzberg as Scotty Simms William Akey as TV Interviewer Thres Jarosek as Kid Spectator Rick Riel as Poker Player Uncredited Aaron Spivey-Sorrells as Coach Spivey Aundrus Poole as Reggie Seale