Special Guest Stars Diane Neal as Assistant D.A. Casey Novak Chloë Sevigny as Christine Hartwell Guest Stars Jenna Stern as Elana Barth Gameela Wright as Jury Foreperson Laura Benanti as Maria Grazie Ron Rifkin as Defense Attorney Marvin Exley Laurie Kennedy as Grandmother Josh Randall as Justin Geld Shawn Hatosy as Kevin Fahey Rich Sommer as Boyd Hartwell Angel Pai as Lien Lucy Fava as Madison Hartwell Matt LoGuercio as Juror Number Seven Johnny Solo as Brad Hayes Carsey Walker, Jr. as Darel Jefferson Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration