Special Guest Stars Joshua Malina as Peter Alpert Martin Landau as Joseph Thomas Guest Stars Holly Maples as Eleanor Prince Andy Comeau as Barry Ness Co Starring Evan Bobrick as Joseph Tancredi Drew Pollock as Marshal Ed (1970's) Fran Martone as Michelle Tancredi Hank Rogerson as Tom Miller Colin Jones as New Reggie J. Ryan Montenery as Reggie (1970's) Emelie O'Hara as Jen (1970's) Roger L. Simon as Louie Morello Ariana Smythe as New Jen Darrel Wayne as Frank Bianchi