Special Guest Stars Alec Baldwin as Jimmy MacArthur Guest Stars Tamara Tunie as Dr. Melinda Warner, M.E. Ami Brabson as Judge Karyn Blake Delaney Williams as Counselor John Buchanan Leslie Odom Jr. as Reverend Curtis Scott Josh Pais as Deputy Commissioner Hank Abraham Manish Dayal as Farid Salim Summer Bishil as Heba Salim Samrat Chakrabarti as Mr. Salim Katie Couric as Herself Nils Lawton as Mike Sullivan Nick Mennell as Elias Kemp Jr. Co Starring John Kinsella as Juror #3 Jacqueline Antaramian as Sakina Salim Sal Inzerillo as Lucius Samantha Tuffarelli as Janelle Hahn Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration