Guest Stars Peter Gallagher as Deputy Chief William Dodds Delaney Williams as Counselor John Buchanan Kathleen Chalfant as Hudson President Rogers Hannah Marks as Evie Barnes Richard T. Jones as Judge Oscar Briggs Casey Thomas Brown as Matt Cooper Max Ehrich as Daniel Pryor Harry Zittel as Justin Adams Co Starring Polly Adams as Jury Foreperson Emily Donahoe as Lisa Barnes Jonathan Strauss as Producer John Leonard Thompson as Bob Barnes Brian Russell as Process Server Karl Jacob as Nate Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration