Guest Stars Annabeth Gish as Alice Sands Nolan North as Phillip Dayton Melody Butiu as A.D.A. Lynne John Asher as Det. O'Connell Dwier Brown as Priest Lisseth Chavez as Carmen Poorna Jagannathan as Mrs. Jalbani Matt Bushell as O'Connell's Partner Aaron Jaeger as Brian McDonald Sean T. Krishnan as Amir Jalbani Co Starring Jaime Collaco as Officer Garcia Scott Broderick as Sam Jacob Timothy Manown as Teenage Dishwasher Kim Delgado as Magistrate