Special Guest Stars Jorja Fox as Sara Sidle Guest Stars Jon Wellner as Henry Andrews Larry Mitchell as Officer Mitchell Alex Carter as Detective Vartann Bill Irwin as Nate Haskell Reggie Watkins as Officer Clark Jack Conley as Jack Herson Lex Medlin as Sgt Barclay Alan Blumenfeld as Bernard Higgins Matt Ross as Charlie DiMasa Jennifer Jean Snyder as Sketch Artist Marty Ingels as Marty Felnick Joseph Bologna as Giovanni "Papa" DiMasa Robert Amico as Joseph Bigelow