Guest Stars Christopher Backus as Rick Bayless Tanc Sade as Christopher House Jacqueline Byers as Natalie Shin Branscombe Richmond as Puna Finesse Mitchell as Harvey Catero Colbert as Tom Staton Brian Benben as Preston Lindsey Buckingham as Himself Rainn Wilson as Bryce Newman Co Starring Jack Yang as Kelton Lamon Archey as Detective Rick Davidson Derek Dow as Steve F. Katherine Murphy as Assistant Christie Herring as Female Detective Andrew Lutheran as Dionne Molly Pan as Ticket Taker Ray Auxais as Ferrone Taylor Marie Frey as Cassie Melinda Hill as Herself Diva Zappa as Caterer