Guest Stars Silas Weir Mitchell as Anthony Brickman John Finn as Detective Henry Doaks Clancy Brown as D.A. Justin Fox Anthony Heald as Judge Wallace Cooper Kaitlin Hopkins as Karen Mills Dougald Park as Zachary Kingman Ted Marcoux as Dennis Mills Dreya Weber as Sister Janice Murray Stan Ivar as Mark Jacobs Eric Saiet as Robert Letterman Co Starring Barbara Allyne-Bennet as Mrs. Reynolds Ralph Remington as Jail Guard