Guest Stars Paige Patterson as Scarlett Pierce Zach Grenier as Dean Healy Megan Hilty as Misty Alise Glenn Fleshler as FBI Agent Aaron Blades Kurt Fuller as J.K. Cornish Jeremy Shamos as FBI Director Louis Marchant David Furr as Dr. Colin Mitchell Rick Holmes as Dr. Jesse Kretchner Co Starring Alana Arenas as Red's Receptionist Olivia Birkelund as Norah Moody Brandon Flynn as Mike the Intern Walker Hare as Man Steven Hauck as Senator Chuck Hodges Paulo Quiros as Jogger