Guest Stars Ken Marino as Jason "C.J." Stentley Maya Rudolph as U.S. Marshal Karen Haas Jim O'Heir as Sheriff Reynolds Esther Povitsky as Emily Co Starring Susan Berger as Ruth Biff Wiff as Tito John Littlefield as Wax Eegan Maurice Webster as Deputy Thom Colin Campbell as Evan Spekesup Jeremy Lawson as Mitch