Guest Stars Rachel Sterling as Madam Caramel Brian T. Finney as John Paul Rudd as Guy Gerricault Patton Oswalt as Boozehammer of Galen Tracey Walter as Sheriff Walter Chechekevitch Magdalena Zielinska as Mrs. Chechekevitch Anand Vadehra as Mrs. Chechekevitch's Boyfriend Uncredited Brian Posehn as Stevie the Coroner